Has potential to be cool. The art is on point. But from what I'm seeing in this video I have to be honest the obstacles do not look challenging or interesting. I'd also say it needs to be even faster.
Godot
Welcome to the programming.dev Godot community!
This is a place where you can discuss about anything relating to the Godot game engine. Feel free to ask questions, post tutorials, show off your godot game, etc.
Make sure to follow the Godot CoC while chatting
We have a matrix room that can be used for chatting with other members of the community here
Links
Other Communities
- !inat@programming.dev
- !play_my_game@programming.dev
- !destroy_my_game@programming.dev
- !voxel_dev@programming.dev
- !roguelikedev@programming.dev
- !game_design@programming.dev
- !gamedev@programming.dev
Rules
- Posts need to be in english
- Posts with explicit content must be tagged with nsfw
- We do not condone harassment inside the community as well as trolling or equivalent behaviour
- Do not post illegal materials or post things encouraging actions such as pirating games
We have a four strike system in this community where you get warned the first time you break a rule, then given a week ban, then given a year ban, then a permanent ban. Certain actions may bypass this and go straight to permanent ban if severe enough and done with malicious intent
Wormhole
Credits
- The icon is a modified version of the official godot engine logo (changing the colors to a gradient and black background)
- The banner is from Godot Design
Very fair criticism! May I ask what you think might make for more interesting obstacles? Different shapes, maybe stuff that moves?
Just from the video:
I couldn't really see the obstacle lasers
Most rooms looked the same
All of them looked rather trivial in difficulty
With the mechanics you do have, you could design some pretty complex obstacles. The showcase video looks mostly like empty rooms. I see promise in the movement, it just needs to be faster.
One important aspect I cant tell from the video is controls. They will most definitely make it if they are silky smooth and intuitive like Mirror's Edge or absolutely ruin the experience if they are clunky.
The simplicity of the obstacles has been mentioned a few times now. We'll definitely take that on board and try to exploit the movement mechanics.
Also, I'm definitely biased, but I think the movement is quite fun! I hope you agree, if you test out the demo.
I'll give it a try when I get to my pc. The movement did look good.
Hey friendo! Did you get a chance to try it out? :)
Yes! Theres a lot of potential. The movement was good though. Definitely take some time to make challenging obstacles
That seems to be the major takeaway. And, as I expected, it's obvious in retrospect haha! I'm considering remaking the levels around actual platforming, with large drops and no easy path. Thanks a ton for your feedback!
No problem! Just DM me if you need some testers again! I think you are on the right path with that idea.
I'll hold you to that haha!
Thanks again :)
If I may be so bold - I have added download links, if you're interested in testing it out.
I'll give it a try so you can have some true feedback on the game and not the trailer. I'll just need an hour or two to get to my pc and play it.
I'm simply happy a stranger is willing to give it a try! I hope the "tutorial" isn't too vague. But in any case, that will definitely get some work, soon.
So far, that has the feel of a good tutorial level - like it's the first challenge faced by the test subject when they first get their abilities, before they realize what's going on and they have to escape.
If that's the starting environment, I could imagine occasional pauses where you describe the next challenge and how to overcome it.
Then, once getting through this area, things start to get faster and more chaotic.
Are you planning on having different speed settings, so the game can be approachable to different kinds of players?
And you know what could be cool? If you manage a perfect phase-dash (i.e. dash at the exact instant a projectile would hit you), it creates a shockwave that deflects all nearby projectiles back at whatever fired them.
(Ignore the slow-mo that totally isn't to compensate for my lack of fast reflexes!)
Sweet! I doubt I'll be good enough to manage that but it's cool that you were able to implement it so quickly.
Haven't had a chance to check out the demo yet, maybe tomorrow night.
That is an incredible idea! That's definitely going on the pile. Thanks for that.
Hmm, you put me in an awkward position. We were planning on simply having this environment ramp up in intensity toward the final room. (The game should really only take about 10 minutes to complete. Something of a proof of concept for us.)
But you throwing out the idea of other environments does tempt me to suggest increasing the scope!
By speed settings, are you referring to player speed, laser grid speed, or some overall speed scale? You raise an interesting point.
Also, if you'd like to try it out, we have builds of the current state of the game to test out: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1jsOXz3Isfp6CTGfL7PfKGCqF4xxdMJjV?usp=sharing
Any feedback is welcome, however incisive, scathing or negative. Positive is nice too, but we can't be too presumptuous :P
Also - if you do increase the scope, you could totally, like, intend the game to be ~10 minutes segments. Maybe release the first segment once you think it's polished enough, see whether you want to add additional areas or environments with more levels and options.
Basically, don't get burned out with scope creep. If you have something that works, release it. Even if you want to add more later. :)
Really, any speed settings would help make the game more accessible and approachable.
Some people may enjoy the parkour elements but not have the motor skills to handle high-speed reactions.
Other folks may be great at the fast paced movement, but get frustrated by the number of enemies or the speed of projectiles.
If you are able to offer sliders (or even just low/medium/high) options for things like movement speed, enemy frequency, damage taken, and grid reaction time? If you can do that without having to remake your code or game engine? It'll mean a much wider potential audience for your game.
Speedrunners and streamers can have fun setting everything to the fastest and hardest difficulties. Casual players can have fun with it without getting frustrated.
And sweet, you've got a Linux build. I do most of my gaming on Linux now. I'll try to check out the demo.
These have all been great suggestions! Thanks so much for the feedback, it will certainly help inform our next moves. And also, thanks for checking out the demo :)
The first ten to fifteen levels look like they'd be tedious to replay after every death. Maybe have them only occur the first run per play session and the timer/restart point begins after that?
Technically it's all random - only the first 2 are set in stone. Though the way the defence generation works, lasers etc only start to phase in after about 10-15 rooms, so that might be what you're picking up on. I could bump those numbers up so defences start spawning earlier, perhaps. It gets genuinely chaotic after a couple dozen rooms!