I've never been to the US but there is cultural diversity within the various groups of the Jewish diaspora and not just across Ashkenazi and Sephardi lines. I have much more in common with Soviet Jews than any other group, for instance, and, within the broader Soviet Jew group, there are further regional distinctions that are not just about cuisine but also the languages we speak, the days we celebrate, etc. Seeing people engaging with this rich cultural diversity being equated to race science and dog breeding right under a comment that praises this community's respect and acceptance is wild, to say the least.
awth13
~~What is the context of this I can't see in the post~~
Nvm found it. Is it race science though or just a shorthand for telling other Jews what your background is like?
"Y'all" as in the American Jews?
Because the Russian government of today doesn't remember and doesn't care about what this day represents. I wish BadComedian's videos on YouTube were translated into English so that English speaking comrades could see for themselves the nightmarish level of farce Russian state-sponsored media turned this memory into: evil NKVD drunkards forcing genetically pure Russian soldiers to die while they survive with the help of God™️ and make friends with SS soldiers because "the Russian soul is so kind", etc. Inviting Israel to the parade is really not the worst of it.
I don't think this is a Marxist perspective. It is founded on an assumption that LLMs are capable of positively transforming creative production in one way or another, be it by raising productivity of existing participants or lowering barriers of entry for new ones. This assumption is false, in my opinion, because there is a difference between abundance and dilution. When the market is flooded with lemons of questionable quality, all that is achieved is intensified information asymmetry, meaning that it becomes harder, more labourious, more expensive to distinguish good lemons from bad ones. This leads to a less productive market overall because sellers have to invest extra labour and money to even have a chance to find buyers while buyers invest the extra to buy or produce information that would help discover the good lemons. A good existing example of this situation is the today's job market.
And if one is to argue that LLM produced slop is the good lemon – or going to be one very soon just you wait Sam Altman / China is developing it so fast! – then they arrive at, in my opinion, the crux of the negative reaction towards the LLM hype. It is not any of the reasons listed in the OP, it is just that people think it is not very useful or good.