At first when I saw this I was eager to explore it: there isn't much choice in terms of open source SSH clients for Android. Termius is proprietary, ConnectBot is unmaintained (but recently has had some new activity?) and JuiceSSH was never open source afaik. Currently I am using Termux + openssh but that's not great either (e.g. no FIDO ssh key support).

However upon further inspection I am a little suspicious that AI is used significantly for a few reasons:

Claude has contributed a few commits (but not many)
Some of the markdown files (like VISION.md) read like AI generated text
The way the author replies to issues and PRs also reads like AI generated text, with heavy use of em dashes and bold text unnecessarily
The rate of commits and new features seems rather high for a single person working by themselves

Are my suspicions founded? Even if the author uses AI to generate documentation and reply to issues, I'm not sure about the actual code itself. SSH access is quite a sensitive thing so I'd like to know whether the client I am using is built with AI or not. Would appreciate your thoughts.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] notabot@piefed.social 9 points 2 months ago

A big problem is that vibe-coded stuff tends to be much harder to maintain as the 'author' diesn't actually know how it works, and the code was not built for humans to understand. That's not a problem that's unique to LLM generated code, but it is common place in code that is, so "was this generated by LLM/AI" becomes a useful proxy question for "is thus codebase likely to be harder to maintain, and thus be less likely to be maintained well?"

There's also the sociatal level costs of using these models to consider. At present, they use significant amounts of power and cooling, both of which lead to adverse environmental effects. It serms quite appropriate to ask if a project using them, and to make the choice to avoid those that are, out of principal as well as technical concern.