Dear god. Why are note-taking projects such a magnet for slop bros?
I'm on a bit of a quest to build up some self-hosted services for me and friends & family, partially because Ad- & AI-infested big tech slop was making me sick and also to become a better sysadmin. General requirement was notes available anywhere and decent editing on mobile.
I was about to rip my hair out, when every session digging into options for weeks ended into frustration. Every project with somewhat decent features had some meh aspects and became worse the longer I looked. And there are so many of them. You can drown your self in "Best FOSS Note-taking App in ${current_year}" listicles. Here's a list of over a hundred projects.
I suspect it's a bit of the shopping list problem. It's such a basic idea, that every ambitious clueless dev has it once while picking a hobby project. But note-taking also definitely has a place in toxix self-optimization / hustle culture. Some of the more developed project strike me as that.
I won't mention every basic note-talking project with a CLAUDE.md that I stumbled on, but here's some of the more disappointing lowlights:
- Joplin main developer was one-shot. Added agent instructions to the repo this year and some provisions from his personal Vibecoding rig to
.gitignore. Also it's not a bug if the AI chat button is visible of AI features are disabled. People have to be informed about the AI features! - Notesnook seems okay-ish, but they're part of the mall ninja club. Business partnership with Kagi & Tuta.
- Standard Notes was the least suspect to me. Later found out they Copilot-Review all of their PRs. (same as Notesnook btw)
- I even considered going with a self-hosted binary of Obsidian. They don't get instant-disqualified by promoting themselves as AI-anything. And if you don't have a project you can trust, you might as well through yourself at the most established option and pray.
I was running out of places to look for alternatives, when I remembered Open Slopware. You can guess how surprised I was, when note-software made up on of the biggest sublists in there. Through the shortlist of recommendations I ended up looking at Flatnotes. That project might just be enough notes for me.