redeux
Thanks for posting this and for pointing it out on my thread (i deleted it as duplicate). Federation must have had a hiccup because this post didn't show up when i searched this morning.
I like to think my rules aren't sketchy, but the closest would be for character building my rules for uncommon and rare options are "tell me a story i can't say no to"
For uncommon options I'm pretty willing to take anything as long as it's not just an obvious power grab. For rare stuff i look more to see how much thought they've put into it and if it would negatively affect the rest of the party.
End result: I've had some pretty freak tables and others where everyone sticks to core ancestries.
I wonder if there will be a new slayer iconic then, since it seemed they used the pf1 slayer iconic Zadim for the pf2 Avenger class archetype